top of page
65.jpg

CONTENT

Authors & Topics

01.jpg

Pavani Joshi

In episode #1 on

Hagia Sophia The finest 
example of political 
influence and power

Hagia Sophia: The finest example of political influence & power to be used as a trophy of political and religious wars is nothing new for Hagia Sophia, but such a thing happening in modern times doesn’t seem right. We have to be more sensitive towards world heritage sites and their rightful place in society.

the graphic.jpg

Hagia Sophia The finest example of political influence and power

An article by Pavani joshi, a student from 5th year B.arch

‘The Hagia Sophia in Istanbul, Turkey, changed the history of architecture - it changed the way people saw space.’

1.jpg

[i]

               

Recently Hagia Sophia, the great landmark of Istanbul lost its status of a museum from the past 80 years and got converted into a mosque. It is a 1500-year-old structure, one of the most important world heritage sites.  It was founded as the church inspired by the east and the west. Located at one of the highland sites in Istanbul its strong influence is visible from the Bosporus Sea. This decision faced a lot of opposing from all across the world declaring ruthless and harsh behavior of the government. Now here the question is, why only this particular structure and the city which is 3000 years old, is being used for the sole purpose of politics? 


Let’s look at the brief history of the structure and the location of today’s Istanbul. They both have a story to tell. Surrounded by the Bosporus Sea from three sides, the land being admired by humans started its adventure long back in the time of neo-gothic age. It served as the capital of three known biggest empires in the world. The land established by Greek King Byzas based on the prophecy of the Oracle of Delphi, which states ‘the new country you will establish will be across from the land of blind’ [ii] indicating the overlooked location across the Bosporus Sea and it’s called Byzantium. After being part of the Roman Empire for several years, around 300 BC, because of the vast development of the Roman Empire in the eastern part, the Romans declared it as the new center of art and culture, called Constantinopolis’ from the name of its founder Constantine. Because the city developed with the marvelous beauty of God & unique location, people used to say, ‘He who concurs Constantinople conquers the world.’[iii] With the great geographical location of connecting two larger continents, it became an important location and the land that everyone wanted to possess.

 

A half-century later Christianity became the official religion of Rome, & Constantinople became the capital of eastern Rome of the Byzantine Empire. In the time of Byzantine Emperor Justinian, the empire flourished. The culture got a true identity where Greek-Roman and Eastern culture melted together with Christianity. During this time Emperor decided to rebuild the old burnt church of Theodosius II with extraordinary size, which was damaged during the Nika revolt. He appointed two architects for the task: Isidoros & Anthemius. The structure was constructed from the materials from all over the region for almost six years. In 537 BC, the church got inaugurated by the Emperor saying ‘let’s praise the Lord for providing me the opportunity to construct such a wondrous place of worship’[iv] and named it HAGIA SOPHIA, which means holy wisdom.’ For another 50 years, the work of mosaics and rebuilding of a 7-meter higher and lighter dome with a pendentive system went on. It has phenomenal mosaics representing the catholic symbols and figures of emperors, the Virgin Mary, and Jesus. It served as the Greek Orthodox cathedral till the 14th C with several repairs and renovations.


In the glorious time of the Byzantine Empire Constantinople became one of the strongest capital. So many times, emperors tried to conquer it, but not until the Ottomans came! After the Fall of Constantinople to the Ottoman Empire in 1453, the first thing Mehmed the Conqueror did was going to Hagia Sophia and converting it into a mosque, to impact the people for adapting the new king and to make them believe in a new religion. This led to cover the symbolic mosaics with plaster, and the minarets were added. Later on, the city went through lots of development and the name changed to Istanbul. Several restorations by Ottomans under Mimar Sinan for the Hagia Sophia dome took place. By the end, many mosques were constructed in the city. Till the early 19th Century, The Ottoman Empire was ruling over the region of turkey with Istanbul as the capital of their empire.
After World War-I, because of the consequences of war, under the leadership of a military commander, Mustafa Kamal Pasha led the Turkish National Moment by forming the republic of Turkey. This ended almost 600 years of ottoman monarch rule. Mustafa Kamal became the first president of Turkey. He introduced many new laws and reforms demolishing old religious traditions and transferred it into a secular constitution for making the turkey more acceptable among European countries for positive modern development. It led to the conversion of the Hagia Sophia to a museum, as an act of secularism respecting both of the religious & the heritage value of the monument. The capital moved to Ankara, and Istanbul was developed as the major economic city and tourism hub. The people and community developed there were more liberal, open-minded, and free to new modern beliefs. In 1996 the Hagia Sophia Museum came under the monuments protected by UNESCO and was declared among the major world heritage sites. While serving as a museum it was open to exploring yet very well monitored and preserved for the visitors and students. The plaster cover over the mosaic was removed, which revealed very beautiful mosaics from the Byzantine era. Analytical learning happened by studying and researching the marvelous structure. The glory of the structure is preserved till now and I was blessed to witness that.  [v]

12.jpg

[i]

From over the last ten years, the government’s political approach has been changing and it is contradicting what Ataturk set in the constitution, in terms of approaching foreign policies, the nature of the customs, and making policies more and more rigid. More Islamic influence and the dominant single leadership of a new president has been seen. Apart from being modern, it seems they have gone back to before 19 C. by their idea of imposing religious rigidity on people. Under the same notion, they passed the law a few months back about changing the museum of Hagia Sophia back into a mosque. The history is repeating to show the religious supremacy. They declared that it will be a pride for the Muslims and it is the right place to use the structure. Apart from the suggestions of UNESCO, they stated that it’s a country’s property and they are free to do anything they want. “Hagia Sophia’s doors will be, as is the case with all our mosques, wide open to all, whether they be foreign or local, Muslim or non-Muslim,” [ii]said President Erdogan. The Hagia Sophia lost its museum status and on July 24th & the first Friday prayer was held and the mosaics were covered with fabric. A lot of people from turkey were happy & a lot of them were against it. Some of them declared it as an act of covering up against down economic conditions. Turkey’s Nobel prize winner, author Orhan Pamuk stated “To convert it back to a mosque is to say to the rest of the world, unfortunately, we are not secular anymore, there are millions of secular Turks lıke me who are crying against this but their voices are not heard, They are not raising their voices because there is no free speech in Turkey to challenge this, and they were afraid of standing up for Atatürk’s decision,” [iii]This decision received a lot of backlashes all across the globe. 


Apart from the contradictory decisions turkey has been made regarding the cultural heritage, Egypt did the opposite to that. Recently, the leading newspaper article from the Middle East stated about developing Christian sites in Cairo for respecting the culture and attracting tourism through their state religion is Islam. Their ambitious plan is to preserve South Sinai’s Saint Catherine area.[iv]


Hagia Sophia has been the major important landmark that has witnessed the rise and the fall of the land of Constantinople. The structure is so marvelous and huge that it can create an impact on one’s mind when you are standing below it. UNESCO stated that the government hasn’t noted any strategies on how they are going to maintain this world heritage site after keeping it all open. At one point when it was a museum, people were visiting from all across, things were well maintained and students were learning. It was the place for both religions and had their values and parts to share under the same roof. The structure used to represent more as an open university for different faiths and culture than just a museum. Apart from the cats which used to live there, things have changed a lot. Just imagine the opportunities if the structure gets converted into an architectural university itself rather than being used as a winning trophy!             

 

References

[i] Photograph taken by author during her visit in 2017

[ii] (Akşit 2015) the prophecy of Delphi about the origin of the land and the region page no. 9

[iii] (Akşit 2015) about Constantinople

[iv] (Akşit 2015) On the day of integration of new church of hagia sophia by emperor Justinian.

[v] Photograph taken by author during her visit in 2017

[vi] (Mikhail 2020) the middle east newspaper article

[vii] Tweeter’ : Turkish Presidency  @trpresidency Jul 11

[viii] Tweeter’: @AudreyTruschke  Jul 1

 

Bibliography:

agency, Russian news. 2020. UNESCO receives no guarantees of Hagia Sophia preservation from Turkey. July 24. Accessed 2020. https://tass.com/society/1182307.

Akşit, İIhan. 2015. capital of three empires: Istanbul . Istanbul: AkşIt KÜltür ve TurIzm Yayincilik .

2020. bbc news, Hagia Sophia: Pope 'pained' as Istanbul museum reverts to mosque. july 12. Accessed 2020. https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-53371341.

Board, By The Editorial. 2020. nytimes . july 22. Accessed 2020. https://www.nytimes.com/2020/07/22/opinion/hagia-sophia-mosque.html.

ENGINEER, IRFAN. 2020. Reconversion of Hagia Sofia: Triumph or tragedy? August 28. Accessed 2020. https://frontline.thehindu.com/world-affairs/triumph-over-harmony/article32267646.ece.

Mikhail, George. 2020. al monitor . august 7. Accessed 2020. al-monitor.com/pulse/originals/2020/08/egypt-restoration-christian-sites-sinai-turkey-hagia-sophia.html#:~:text=Cairo%20denounces%20Hagia%20Sophia%20move%2C%20develops%20Egypt's%20Christian%20sites,-Days%20after%20Turkish.

Naqvi, Saeed. 2020. Saeed Naqvi | Will Erdogan’s Islamist play at Hagia Sophia rescue his govt? august 10. https://www.deccanchronicle.com/opinion/columnists/130820/saeed-naqvi-will-erdogans-islamist-play-at-hagia-sophia-rescue-hi.html.

ROMEY, KRISTIN. 2020. Hagia Sophia stripped of museum status, paving its return to a mosque. july 10. Accessed 2020. https://api.nationalgeographic.com/distribution/public/amp/history/2020/07/hagia-sophia-stripped-museum-status-paving-way-mosque.

2020. Turkey ‘re-conquers’ Hagia Sophia amid international disapproval. July 24. Accessed 2020. https://www.arabnews.com/node/1710021/middle-east.

unesco. 2020. UNESCO statement on Hagia Sophia, Istanbul. July 10. Accessed 2020. https://en.unesco.org/news/unesco-statement-hagia-sophia-istanbul.

war?, bbc news Hagia Sophia: Why is this museum-turned-mosque at the centre of a culture. 2020. July 24. Accessed 2020. https://www.bbc.com/news/av/world-53528873.

bottom of page